Hey guys, Crazy Nate here! I decided to check out 1993's Benny & Joon, and honestly, I walked away feeling a bit let down. I'm giving this one a 3 out of 5 stars. It's not a bad movie by any means, but it's definitely not one I have any desire to rewatch.
The Performances
Mary Stuart Masterson plays Joon, and to me, her performance felt far more believable as an artist who simply sees life through a unique, visual set of eyes rather than just fitting into a specific diagnosis. On the flip side, Johnny Depp's role as Sam felt a bit forced at times - almost more like a class clown putting on an act rather than someone naturally on the spectrum (if "spectrum" is even the right word to describe him!).
I will say, Aidan Quinn did a solid job as the older brother, Benny, balancing the heavy burden of caretaking with trying to have a life of his own.
A Missed Connection
Advertisement
My biggest issue with the film is that it just isn't very deep. Even by the time the credits roll, you don't really feel like you know any of the characters. Aside from the two main gifted leads, the rest of the cast feels under-developed, and even Joon and Sam remain pretty surface-level throughout.
What makes it even crazier is that Johnny Depp filmed this right around the same time as What's Eating Gilbert Grape. His acting in Gilbert Grape was absolute top-tier, masterpiece material, so going into Benny & Joon, I was expecting something just as powerful. Having those high expectations is probably why I felt so disappointed when the movie finished.
Final Verdict
If you are a huge fan of Johnny Depp, it is worth watching at least once to see his physical comedy and homage to classic silent film stars. But if you're looking for his best work, I definitely wouldn't put this anywhere near his top movies.
My Rating: 3 / 5 Stars
If Benny & Joon is one of your favorites, sign in with your Discord account and defend it in the comments! Share a smile - they're contagious!




Comment on Crazy Nate's Review
Loading...
Want to chat more? Join the conversation in our Discord